TL;DR
Get everyday essentials delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Guillermo Rodriguez and professional partner Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars after the show’s Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode. Jimmy Kimmel criticized the result on Jimmy Kimmel Live, citing the pair’s YouTube views and their judges’ scores while jokingly blaming viewers.
Jimmy Kimmel criticized Dancing with the Stars voters after Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated from the competition following Tuesday night’s Super Bowl-themed episode. On Jimmy Kimmel Live, Kimmel pointed to the pair’s online video views and their judges’ scores as he reacted to the result, though those figures do not establish how viewers voted.
Kimmel said Rodriguez and Carson had made it to Week 5 and had become popular online. He displayed YouTube figures for the previous week: their performances had 719,000 views, compared with 231,000 for Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson, whom Kimmel described as the next-highest pair. Those counts measure video views; they do not reveal the number or distribution of votes cast.
Rodriguez and Carson danced a salsa to a Bad Bunny song during the Super Bowl-themed show. The judges awarded them 22 points out of 40: Carrie Ann Inaba gave them 6, Derek Hough 5, Joe Buck 6 and Bruno Tonioli 5. Kimmel called the dance an “11 out of 10” in his own view and noted that 22 was their highest score yet, according to his remarks.
Kimmel said Rodriguez was again in the bottom two and had depended on audience votes to continue. After the elimination, he spoke with the pair backstage. Asked whether they would accept the result or take legal action, Rodriguez jokingly answered that they should take legal action, and Carson agreed. The exchange was presented as banter; no actual legal action was reported.
DWTS · Week 5 Recap · October 14, 2026
Jimmy Kimmel Calls Out Voters Following Guillermo Rodriguez’s DWTS Departure
After Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars, Jimmy Kimmel questioned the result on his late-night show. His case leaned on online attention and judges’ scores—but neither reveals the audience vote totals.
“Last week, Guillermo and Witney had more than triple the YouTube views of their closest opponent.”Jimmy Kimmel · On-air reaction
The view counts were part of Kimmel’s argument as a joke and reaction. They do not show how viewers voted during the competition.
Online attention, judges’ points
Kimmel compared last week’s video views and highlighted the pair’s highest judges’ score of the season, according to his remarks.
More than triple
Their performances had 719,000 views, versus 231,000 for Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson, the next-highest pair Kimmel presented.
Salsa to Bad Bunny
Rodriguez and Carson danced a salsa during the Week 5 episode. Kimmel called it an “11 out of 10” in his own view.
Eliminated after Week 5
Despite the attention and their best judges’ total yet, the pair left the competition. Kimmel said Rodriguez was again in the bottom two.
A video view is not a competition vote. The comparison illustrates the online reach Kimmel cited; it cannot establish the number or distribution of votes.
22 points out of 40
The four judges’ scores totaled 22. Kimmel described it as Rodriguez and Carson’s highest score of the season.
Views are not votes
The segment made a pointed comparison, but the reported figures leave key parts of the competition result unknown.
Reported
Video views for selected performances, the judges’ 22-point total, the elimination, and Kimmel’s comments about the pair’s bottom-two appearances.
Not provided
Audience vote totals, the complete contestant ranking, or the exact method and weighting used to combine judges’ scores with audience votes.
What follows
The YouTube comparison cannot show whether the pair received more competition votes than another couple or establish that voting was unfair.
Legal-action joke
Asked backstage whether they would accept the result or take legal action, Rodriguez joked that they should sue; Carson agreed. No legal action was reported.
From dance to departure
Rodriguez, a longtime figure on Kimmel’s show, competed with professional dancer Witney Carson.
The pair performed a salsa to a Bad Bunny song in Week 5.
Judges gave them 22 points; Kimmel cited 719,000 video views.
Rodriguez and Carson were sent home after the episode.
Kimmel spoke with the pair and joked about a legal challenge.
Dedication Night is scheduled
The report says the next episode follows the elimination, while leaving future results unknown.
Online Attention Did Not Secure Their Place
The elimination highlights a distinction between online popularity and competition votes. Kimmel’s comparison showed that Rodriguez and Carson’s video had more views than the next-highest clip he presented, but YouTube views are not the same as votes cast during the show. The figures therefore support Kimmel’s argument as a television joke and reaction, not as proof that voting was unfair or that the pair should have remained.
The episode also puts the show’s two scoring elements in view: the judges’ assessment and the audience vote. Rodriguez and Carson received their best judges’ total of the season, according to Kimmel, yet were eliminated. The available account does not give the full vote totals or explain how each component contributed to the final outcome, so the precise reason for their placement cannot be determined from the figures shown on the late-night program.
Dancing with the Stars official fan voting app
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Rodriguez’s Five-Week DWTS Run
Rodriguez, known as a longtime figure on Kimmel’s late-night program, competed with professional dancer Witney Carson. Kimmel had publicly supported the pair during their run, and his reaction to the elimination was framed around that relationship. His comments included praise for Carson’s choreography and a joking reference to a “custody battle” over Rodriguez after the competition.
The elimination came at the end of the show’s Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode. The account says Rodriguez had been in the bottom two more than once and relied on audience support to remain in the contest. The program is broadcast on ABC and Disney+ on Tuesday nights at 8 p.m. ET/PT, with episodes streaming on Hulu the following day, according to the report.
“Last week, Guillermo and Witney had more than triple the YouTube views of their closest opponent.”
— Jimmy Kimmel
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Vote Totals Were Not Provided
The account does not provide the audience vote totals, the complete ranking of contestants, or the method used to combine voting with judges’ scores for this episode. It is not possible to establish from the reported YouTube figures whether Rodriguez and Carson had more votes than another pair. Kimmel’s description of the result as an outrage was his reaction, not evidence of a voting irregularity.
The report also does not include a statement from the show’s producers about the elimination or the voting process. No claim of a formal challenge or legal case was confirmed; the legal-action exchange took place as a joke during the backstage interview.
judge score display for dance competitions
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Dedication Night Follows the Elimination
The next episode is scheduled as Dedication Night, according to the report. Dancing with the Stars airs Tuesday at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+, with streaming on Hulu the following day. The account does not specify which contestants will be eliminated next or provide any further details about the upcoming episode.
Kimmel’s comments are likely to keep the conversation around Rodriguez’s exit focused on the difference between the pair’s online audience and the show’s voting result. Unless the program releases additional voting information, the total votes and the precise breakdown behind the elimination remain unavailable.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
audience voting system for TV shows
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
Who was eliminated from Dancing with the Stars?
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated after the Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode, according to the report.
What score did Rodriguez and Carson receive?
The judges gave the pair 22 points out of 40: Inaba scored them 6, Hough 5, Buck 6 and Tonioli 5.
Why did Jimmy Kimmel criticize voters?
Kimmel questioned the outcome after citing the pair’s YouTube views and their judges’ score. The report does not provide audience vote totals, and video views do not establish how people voted.
Did Guillermo Rodriguez or Witney Carson take legal action?
No legal action was reported. Rodriguez and Carson joked about suing when Kimmel asked whether they would accept the result or take legal action.
What is the next Dancing with the Stars theme?
The next episode is scheduled to feature Dedication Night. The show airs Tuesday at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+, with next-day streaming on Hulu.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
